Santana, only 27, batting 4th
Headley will be lucky to get 22 hrs
0
Who to keep - Santana or Headley?
Started by
Runelvys Hernandez
, Dec 23 2012 08:32 PM
23 replies to this topic
#22
Runelvys Hernandez
-
- Members
-
- 118 posts
Rookie
Posted 18 January 2013 - 05:31 PM
parrothead, on 10 January 2013 - 05:57 PM, said:
Runelvys Hernandez, on 23 December 2012 - 08:32 PM, said:
12 team 6X6 mixed (+OBP and L), $275 cap, 5 keepers. I have 4 no-brainer keepers. They are:
Trout - $7
C. Gonzalez - $11
Cano - $26
Beltre - $18
For my 5th keeper, I have what seems like a no-brainer: Chase Headley at $4. However, I already have a 3B, and catcher is always a thin position. I could keep Carlos Santana (who I love next year) for $10. Should Santana be in considerations for this spot, or should I go with the cheap Headley (who I don't love, but is easily worth $4) and forget it?
Leave a link for help on yours.
Trout - $7
C. Gonzalez - $11
Cano - $26
Beltre - $18
For my 5th keeper, I have what seems like a no-brainer: Chase Headley at $4. However, I already have a 3B, and catcher is always a thin position. I could keep Carlos Santana (who I love next year) for $10. Should Santana be in considerations for this spot, or should I go with the cheap Headley (who I don't love, but is easily worth $4) and forget it?
Leave a link for help on yours.
1 catcher league - so the catcher position isn't as much a necessity to lock up.
10th year of a 12-team 6X6 (+OBP and Losses) H2H Keeper League (5 keepers, +$3 every year kept, $275 cap, 25-man rosters)
Champions 2007, 2009, 2012
C - R. Doumit ($1)
1B - B. Butler ($33)
2B - R. Cano ($26)
3B - A. Beltre ($18)
SS - B. Zobrist ($22)
OF - C. Gonzalez ($11), M. Trout ($7), R. Braun ($58)
Util - C. Headley ($4), S. Choo ($14), S. Marte ($4)
Bench - A. LaRoche ($11), J. Morneau ($2)
SP - M. Bumgarner ($23), J. Zimmermann ($19), H. Iwakuma ($2), I. Kennedy ($6), T. Hudson ($9), A. Pettitte ($1), W. Chen ($1), A. Cashner ($1)
RP - T. Wilhemsen ($8), A. Reed ($8), D. Hernandez ($1), K. Uehara ($1)
Champions 2007, 2009, 2012
C - R. Doumit ($1)
1B - B. Butler ($33)
2B - R. Cano ($26)
3B - A. Beltre ($18)
SS - B. Zobrist ($22)
OF - C. Gonzalez ($11), M. Trout ($7), R. Braun ($58)
Util - C. Headley ($4), S. Choo ($14), S. Marte ($4)
Bench - A. LaRoche ($11), J. Morneau ($2)
SP - M. Bumgarner ($23), J. Zimmermann ($19), H. Iwakuma ($2), I. Kennedy ($6), T. Hudson ($9), A. Pettitte ($1), W. Chen ($1), A. Cashner ($1)
RP - T. Wilhemsen ($8), A. Reed ($8), D. Hernandez ($1), K. Uehara ($1)
#23
uspsjeter2
-
- Established Members
-
- 652 posts
Allstar
- Gender:Male
- Location:Louisville
Posted 24 January 2013 - 05:27 AM
I suggest Santana. Read what was said about these two just one year ago, and you'd be asking yourself if Chase Headley was even rosterable. He had one incredibly good half, Santana one incredibly bad one. Headley hit 27 HR's in his previous 1300 AB's prior to last season. He hit HR's at 4X his previous major league averages, 6X as often in the 2nd half. I'm not betting on anything like a repeat. And you're assuming his average won't regress to historical trends. Plus Santana gives you multi-position eligibility.
"A Humble Man of Grace and Dignity. A Captain Who Led by Example. Proud of the Pinstripes Tradition and Dedicated to the Pursuit of Excellence. A Yankee Forever." Don Mattingly's plaque in Monument Park
#24
RNiner
-
- Members
-
- 471 posts
Veteran
- Location:Montreal
Posted 24 January 2013 - 10:25 AM
Headley, and its really not all that close.
Santana is a nice player, but he shouldn't be going for more then 15-20$. Headley will likely command ~$30 at least.
Even a 20 HR/15 SB campaign from Headley will make his $4 price tag a steal... Santana is likely to justify a $10 price tag imo.
Santana is a nice player, but he shouldn't be going for more then 15-20$. Headley will likely command ~$30 at least.
Even a 20 HR/15 SB campaign from Headley will make his $4 price tag a steal... Santana is likely to justify a $10 price tag imo.
20 Team Roto Keeper League, 5x5 (OBP replaces AVG)
9 Keepers*
C Mauer*
1B Goldschmidt*
2B Utley*
3B Moustakas*
SS
OF Trout*, Trumbo*
Util
Bench Billy Hamilton*
SP
RP Kimbrel*, Jansen*
Prospects - Dylan Bundy, Carlos Martinez, Taijuan Walker, Tyler Thornburg, Kolton Wong, Anthony Gose
9 Keepers*
C Mauer*
1B Goldschmidt*
2B Utley*
3B Moustakas*
SS
OF Trout*, Trumbo*
Util
Bench Billy Hamilton*
SP
RP Kimbrel*, Jansen*
Prospects - Dylan Bundy, Carlos Martinez, Taijuan Walker, Tyler Thornburg, Kolton Wong, Anthony Gose
0 user(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users
