uspsjeter2, on 09 February 2013 - 08:34 PM, said:
Keeping Posey over Tulo makes more sense for several reasons. His stats at catcher are simply more valuable because they are from a catcher. The Giants are focused on Posey's health and give him days at 1B to help avoid wear and tear. Tulo has never played a full season. Health is a skill and he simply doesn't own it. Posey has twice in 3 years finished the season. And by your own admission a Tulo-type player should fall to you in the draft. Keep Posey.
C has become deeper then SS, so i disagree there.
People get on Tulo for missing time.
Posey has 1 year of more then 108 games. Posey has had 1 great year.
Tulo has 4 years with over 108 games. Tulo has 4 great years, a longer track record.
Posey is great, but his babip was lucky last year, C rest a lot, and they get dinged up more then anybody.