Tean in signature
He offered
I give Scherzer
I get MYoung/AJBurnett
Thinking about countering with
I give Scherzer/Keppinger
I get Headley
My staff is solid but I don't know if it can survive the hit of losing Scherzer. There are some good FA pitchers on the WW, but none come close to the strikeouts I lose.
Headley would give me a stronger piece to trade (either him or Wright) to getting a true ace.
Last year was my first year playing and this forum drilled into my head that bats before pitching
Opinions?
WHIR as always and to be polite
0
Help in Redraft Trade
Started by
An Old Hippie
, Feb 12 2013 06:10 PM
5 replies to this topic
#1
An Old Hippie
-
- Established Members
-
- 1,893 posts
Superstar
- Gender:Male
Posted 12 February 2013 - 06:10 PM
10 Team H2H Keep 5 Standard categories Record 40-18-2
C-Montero (ARI)
1st-Encarnacion
2nd-Rutledge
SS-Escobar
3rd-Zimmerman
2nd/SS-Gordon
1st/3rd-Fielder
OF-Braun, Morse, Crawford, Saunders,
UTL-Gordon
BN-Jennings, Donaldson, Scutero, Carter
D/L-Hill
SP-Wainwright, Harvey, Medlin, Lynn, Minor, Cobb, Ryu, Lohse, Cingrani, Cashner
RP-None
C-Montero (ARI)
1st-Encarnacion
2nd-Rutledge
SS-Escobar
3rd-Zimmerman
2nd/SS-Gordon
1st/3rd-Fielder
OF-Braun, Morse, Crawford, Saunders,
UTL-Gordon
BN-Jennings, Donaldson, Scutero, Carter
D/L-Hill
SP-Wainwright, Harvey, Medlin, Lynn, Minor, Cobb, Ryu, Lohse, Cingrani, Cashner
RP-None
#2
RyanksN
-
- Established Members
-
- 1,581 posts
Superstar
- Gender:Male
- Location:CT
Posted 12 February 2013 - 06:42 PM
I like trade 2 better....#1 makes sence if you have alot of SP which it seems as you might be on the thinner side.
1.)CBS Auction Dynasty 5x5 Standard Roto (12 team)13 Keepers + 3 Minor League Keepers
$260 for 23 player (Also have 17 player bench not included in Auction Draft)
Batters (11) C(2)-Arrencibia $6, McCann $5 1st- A.Gonzo $39, 2nd- Altuve $1, 3rd- Hanley $31, SS- Desmond $1, CI- R.Howard $11, MI- Rutledge $2, OF(5)- J.Upton $26, Cespedas $11, J.Heyward $11, Pagan $4, D.Brown $6 DH- Pujols $63
BN - Pollock, Wells, Carpenter, Hundley, Norris, Reimold, C.Young
Pitchers (4) SP(6)- C.Sale $7, Scherzer $11, Lynn $5, J.Fernandez $10, Miley $1, Ogando $7RP(4)- S.Romo $4, C.Janssen $6, B.Parnell $3
BN - McCarthy, Slowey, Casilla, Russell
Minors - C.Martinez, T.Skaggs, T.Walker, N. Castelanos, D.Deshields, J.Paxton
2.)CBS Auction Dynasty Points League (12 team)10 Keepers + 2 Minor League Keepers
$300 for 18 players (Also have 12 player bench not included in Auction Draft)
Scoring: 1 pt = rbi, run, bb, sac, 2 pt= sb, 2.5 pt = dbl, 4 pt = hr, 5 pt = tpl, -1 =k
1 pt = IP, 2 pt = k, 3 pt = qs, hld, 4 pt = w, 5 pt = sv, 7.5 pt = cg, so, -1 pt = bb, er, -3 pts = loss
Batters (10) C- Doumit $1, 1st-F.Freeman $26, 2nd- Kipnis $28, 3rd- M.Carpenter $11, SS- Prado $20, OF(3)-McCutchens $50, L.Cain $5, Cuddyer $3, DH (2)- J.Rutledge $3, M.Teixiera $5
Pitchers (8) SP(5)- A.Wainwright $20, M.Scherzer $23, M.Moore $26, J.Zimmerman $17, M.Minor $12 RP(3)- S.Miller $12, M.Rivera $12, A.Ogando $13 BN- Bauer $11, Hellickson $8, McCarthy $2, Janssen $1
$260 for 23 player (Also have 17 player bench not included in Auction Draft)
Batters (11) C(2)-Arrencibia $6, McCann $5 1st- A.Gonzo $39, 2nd- Altuve $1, 3rd- Hanley $31, SS- Desmond $1, CI- R.Howard $11, MI- Rutledge $2, OF(5)- J.Upton $26, Cespedas $11, J.Heyward $11, Pagan $4, D.Brown $6 DH- Pujols $63
BN - Pollock, Wells, Carpenter, Hundley, Norris, Reimold, C.Young
Pitchers (4) SP(6)- C.Sale $7, Scherzer $11, Lynn $5, J.Fernandez $10, Miley $1, Ogando $7RP(4)- S.Romo $4, C.Janssen $6, B.Parnell $3
BN - McCarthy, Slowey, Casilla, Russell
Minors - C.Martinez, T.Skaggs, T.Walker, N. Castelanos, D.Deshields, J.Paxton
2.)CBS Auction Dynasty Points League (12 team)10 Keepers + 2 Minor League Keepers
$300 for 18 players (Also have 12 player bench not included in Auction Draft)
Scoring: 1 pt = rbi, run, bb, sac, 2 pt= sb, 2.5 pt = dbl, 4 pt = hr, 5 pt = tpl, -1 =k
1 pt = IP, 2 pt = k, 3 pt = qs, hld, 4 pt = w, 5 pt = sv, 7.5 pt = cg, so, -1 pt = bb, er, -3 pts = loss
Batters (10) C- Doumit $1, 1st-F.Freeman $26, 2nd- Kipnis $28, 3rd- M.Carpenter $11, SS- Prado $20, OF(3)-McCutchens $50, L.Cain $5, Cuddyer $3, DH (2)- J.Rutledge $3, M.Teixiera $5
Pitchers (8) SP(5)- A.Wainwright $20, M.Scherzer $23, M.Moore $26, J.Zimmerman $17, M.Minor $12 RP(3)- S.Miller $12, M.Rivera $12, A.Ogando $13 BN- Bauer $11, Hellickson $8, McCarthy $2, Janssen $1
#3
ComericanPie
-
- Established Members
-
- 1,353 posts
Superstar
Posted 12 February 2013 - 06:49 PM
The counter is definitely better than the original offer IMO. I just don't think it's worth the dropoff from Scherzer to Burnett just for Michael Young alone.
#4
uspsjeter2
-
- Established Members
-
- 638 posts
Allstar
- Gender:Male
- Location:Louisville
Posted 12 February 2013 - 09:23 PM
ComericanPie, on 12 February 2013 - 06:49 PM, said:
The counter is definitely better than the original offer IMO. I just don't think it's worth the dropoff from Scherzer to Burnett just for Michael Young alone.
Glad the bats before pitching drill has held! However if you have a great pitching staff there's no rush to dismantle it either. I suggest patience and not long into the season someone at a position you need will start slowly, and you can swoop in and nab him with your pitching riches.
"A Humble Man of Grace and Dignity. A Captain Who Led by Example. Proud of the Pinstripes Tradition and Dedicated to the Pursuit of Excellence. A Yankee Forever." Don Mattingly's plaque in Monument Park
#5
An Old Hippie
-
- Established Members
-
- 1,893 posts
Superstar
- Gender:Male
Posted 13 February 2013 - 12:04 AM
Changed the counter offer where I get Harper and give up Schrezer.
Starting 5 outfielders I'd like to have more upside and a little more depth. I may not pick up another pitcher with the K potential then Schrezer has but then I won't get an outfielder off the WW with Harpers ceiling either.
Other thing is it keeps the dialog going as I really doubt he will accept the trade. But he is a he a Tiger fan, at least by the players he drafted, so the possibility exists that he might.
Starting 5 outfielders I'd like to have more upside and a little more depth. I may not pick up another pitcher with the K potential then Schrezer has but then I won't get an outfielder off the WW with Harpers ceiling either.
Other thing is it keeps the dialog going as I really doubt he will accept the trade. But he is a he a Tiger fan, at least by the players he drafted, so the possibility exists that he might.
10 Team H2H Keep 5 Standard categories Record 40-18-2
C-Montero (ARI)
1st-Encarnacion
2nd-Rutledge
SS-Escobar
3rd-Zimmerman
2nd/SS-Gordon
1st/3rd-Fielder
OF-Braun, Morse, Crawford, Saunders,
UTL-Gordon
BN-Jennings, Donaldson, Scutero, Carter
D/L-Hill
SP-Wainwright, Harvey, Medlin, Lynn, Minor, Cobb, Ryu, Lohse, Cingrani, Cashner
RP-None
C-Montero (ARI)
1st-Encarnacion
2nd-Rutledge
SS-Escobar
3rd-Zimmerman
2nd/SS-Gordon
1st/3rd-Fielder
OF-Braun, Morse, Crawford, Saunders,
UTL-Gordon
BN-Jennings, Donaldson, Scutero, Carter
D/L-Hill
SP-Wainwright, Harvey, Medlin, Lynn, Minor, Cobb, Ryu, Lohse, Cingrani, Cashner
RP-None
#6
thump
-
- Members
-
- 11 posts
Single-A
Posted 13 February 2013 - 12:51 AM
He would be silly to accept that deal..
0 user(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users
