Help in Redraft Trade
Posted 12 February 2013 - 06:10 PM
I give Scherzer
I get MYoung/AJBurnett
Thinking about countering with
I give Scherzer/Keppinger
I get Headley
My staff is solid but I don't know if it can survive the hit of losing Scherzer. There are some good FA pitchers on the WW, but none come close to the strikeouts I lose.
Headley would give me a stronger piece to trade (either him or Wright) to getting a true ace.
Last year was my first year playing and this forum drilled into my head that bats before pitching
WHIR as always and to be polite
Posted 12 February 2013 - 06:42 PM
1.)CBS Auction Dynasty 5x5 Standard Roto (12 team)10 Keepers + 3 Minor League Keepers
$260 for 23 player (Also have 17 player bench not included in Auction Draft)
Batters (11) C(2)-Weiters $7, Chirinos $1 1st- Goldy $47, 2nd-D.Travis $4 3rd- K.Bryant $5, SS- A.Ramirez $4, CI-P.Fielder $17 MI-Tulo $48 OF(5)- G.Stanton $33, C.Dickerson $8, J.Pederson$5, M.Taylor $1, L.Martin $10 DH- E.Hosmer $3
BN - J.Baez $4, C.Ruiz, Alcantera, Jace Peterson, J.Werth, E.Cabrerra, A.Gose
Minors -J.Alfaro, D.Dahl, J.Winker
Pitchers (4) SP(6)- , D.Keuchel $7, Bumgarner $26, Teharan $18, Y.Ventura $5, Pineda $4, K.Graveman $2 RP(3)- K.Jansen $6, S.Casilla $2, J.Mejia $2
BN - Sabathia, J.Peralta, M.Minor
Minors- J.Urias, M.Appel, M.Wisler
2.)CBS Auction Dynasty Points League (12 team)10 Keepers + 2 Minor League Keepers
$300 for 18 players (Also have 12 player bench not included in Auction Draft)
Scoring: 1 pt = rbi, run, bb, sac, 2 pt= sb, 2.5 pt = dbl, 4 pt = hr, 5 pt = tpl, -1 =k
1 pt = IP, 2 pt = k, 3 pt = qs, hld, 4 pt = w, 5 pt = sv, 7.5 pt = cg, so, -1 pt = bb, er, -3 pts = loss
Batters (10) C- Weiters $22, 1st-F.Freeman $26, 2nd- Carpenter $11, 3rd- Arenado $11, SS- Jeter $1, OF(3)-McCutchens $50, W.Meyers $12, Gorden $7, DH (2)- A.Gon $22, Votto $49 BN-.A.Ram, Asdrubal, Cain, Pollock, Hansen, Seager, Soler
Pitchers (8) SP(5)- A.Wainwright $20, M.Scherzer $23, J.Zimmerman $17, M.Minor $12, Skaggs $1 RP(3)- S.Miller $12, A.Reed $2, A.Ogando $1 BN-.Miley $1, Paxton $9, E.Santana $12, Carrasco $8, A.Heaney $7
Posted 12 February 2013 - 06:49 PM
Posted 12 February 2013 - 09:23 PM
I'd do neither trade. Young's only valuable skill now is positional flexibilty, and he's not projected to hit high in the Phillies lineup. Burnett is on the backside of his career and primed for regression pitching for a lousy team. Scherzer is on the cusp of greatness and plays for the best team on paper maybe in all of baseball. I don't see this as upgrading your roster.
The counter is definitely better than the original offer IMO. I just don't think it's worth the dropoff from Scherzer to Burnett just for Michael Young alone.
Glad the bats before pitching drill has held! However if you have a great pitching staff there's no rush to dismantle it either. I suggest patience and not long into the season someone at a position you need will start slowly, and you can swoop in and nab him with your pitching riches.
Posted 13 February 2013 - 12:04 AM
Starting 5 outfielders I'd like to have more upside and a little more depth. I may not pick up another pitcher with the K potential then Schrezer has but then I won't get an outfielder off the WW with Harpers ceiling either.
Other thing is it keeps the dialog going as I really doubt he will accept the trade. But he is a he a Tiger fan, at least by the players he drafted, so the possibility exists that he might.