Vick will be one of the highest scoring QBs in that offense if he can stay healthy. I like Garcon over Decker. Garcon is the #1 guy while Decker is #3 or #4. Foster is obviously more valuable than Tate. It's not veto worthy but it's not a trade I would do.
Not seeing the issue.. Who knows if Tate could overtake Foster at some point with his injury/production issues. Vick is an upgrade over Manning. I've been trying to trade for Vick and I own manning. Garcon is on fire in a pass happy offense.
Other Way: Foster could step up his game and be an animal the rest of the way, Decker has a Hall of Fame QB throwing to him and is productive.. Manning, albeit inconsistent can put up serious numbers. Not a great deal, but far from veto worthy.
If 2 owners agree on a trade then it should never be vetoed. I've come to learn that in my time on these forums. Both guys obviously saw value in what they're getting, so who cares if it seems unfair to anyone else.
jumpman--jumpman--jumpman them boys up to somethin
12-Team 1-PPR 20-Team 1-PPR
QB:Big BenQB: Fitzpatrick
RB:Forsett RB: D. Lewis
RB:D. Lewis -- Ivory, Woodhead, Hillman RB: CJ Spiller -- Matt Jones, Hillman, Blount
WR:A. Brown WR: A. Cooper
WR:Crabtree -- D. Adams, John Brown, B. Cooks WR: Steve Smith Sr. -- T. Williams, B. Cooks, B. Butler
I don't know. It looks okay. Basically, Vick for Foster. Decker can either be a dud or a stud. Garcon is the better WR. Tate is a backup and Eli is garbage.
12 person (2QB auction league) QB: Eli Manning (NYG), Alex Smith (KC), Jason Campbell (Cle); Scott Tolzien (GB); Ryan Fitzpatrick (Ten) WR: Jordy Nelson (GB), Michael Crabtree (SF), Riley Cooper (Phi); Rishard Matthews (Mia); Jericho Cotchery (Pit) RB: Giovani Bernard (Cin), Shane Vereen (NE); Rashad Jennings (Oak) TE: Tony Gonzalez (Atl) K: Stephen Gostkowski DEF: Carolina
12 person (standard league) QB: Mike Glennon (TB); Russell Wilson (Sea) WR: Demaryius Thomas (Den), Calvin Johnson (Det), Brandon Marshall (Chi), Keenan Allen (SD) RB: Zac Stacy (StL), Steven Jackson (Atl), Andre Ellington (Ari), Andre Brown (NYG); Rashad Jennings (Oak) TE: Rob Gronkowski (NE), Julius Thomas (Den) K: Stephen Gostkowski DEF: Houston
If vick is healthy he'll be a qb1. I wouldnt veto it. If at the end of the season vick is the top scoring qb and foster is injured and tate puts up rb1 numbers what will you tell team 1? Last season a trade was vetoed in my league. Mccoy for spiller and morris after week 1. Everyone said the team giving up mccoy was being ripped off, but if the trade went though he would of won the league getting two rb1's.
Team 1 10 Team Standard
Qb Brady rb D. Murray AP wr Matthews Cooks Te Rudolph Flex Adams D/st Miami k bryant
Bn qb Bridgewater rb Foster wr Watkins wr Allen
Team 2 12 Team Standard
qb E. Manning rb ivory bernard wr Megatron Matthews te Gronk flex Edelman D/st Colts k Vinatieri
bn rb Foster Spiller Vereen M.Jones wr Watkins Team 3 12 Team .5 PPR
Qb rodgers rb ivory Gordon wr Cobb Adams Landry flex Edelman te eifert d/st colts k parkey
Bn rb l. bell yeldon t. coleman hillman spiller wr c. Johnson Team 4 10 team auction .5 ppr
Qb Peyton rb l. Murray Bernard wr Matthews Evans flex Hopkins te walker d/st Dolphins k vinateri
Bn Qb Eli rb l. Bell T. Coleman spiller wr Edelman Landry
Team 5 12 Team Standard
qb Brees rb AP Randle wr Green Cobb Sanders te Rudolph d/st Colts k Parkey
bn rb Foster Spiller Crowell Freeman wr M. Wallace
I agree with Bwells, as a commissioner in my league, I dont think I've ever vetoed a trade. The only reason I would, is if it there were obvious signs of collusion. You have to remember, in a competitive league, NO ONE likes seeing teams improve and it's in ur interest to vote down a trade or veto it. Seems to me like both these guys are trying to improve their teams, although the trade is loopsided.