Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

baltimore_boy

Awards Thread

9 posts in this topic

I thought I'd start this off with some projections.

MVP - Tom Brady

Offensive Player - Adrian Peterson

Offensive ROY - Andrew Luck

Defensive Player - Aldon Smith

Defnsive ROY - Luke Kuechly

Coach - Mike Shanahan

Comeback - Adrian Peterson

Who do you have to win?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

MVP - Peyton Manning

Offensive Player - Adrian Peterson

Offensive ROY - Andrew Luck

Defensive Player - JJ Watt

Defnsive ROY - Luke Kuechly

Coach - Gary Kubiak or Mike Smith

Comeback - Peyton Manning

Not sure if that Shanny for coach of the year was a joke or not. I can honestly see PM winning Comeback and MVP. He took the entire year off after neck surgery while AP missed 3 games even though he suffered a serious injury and came back earlier than most expected. Both are big candidates but I see Manning edging him out.

Hell, I wouldnt be surprised if AP won both either, you can make an arguement for both guys winning both awards.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

MVP- Virgil Green

Offensive player of the year- Virgil Green

Offensive ROY- Virgil Green

Defensive player of the year- Virgil Green (He'll find a way to win it)

Defensive ROY- Virgil Green

Coach- Virgil Green

Comeback- Virgil Green

He's just too good.

2 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm assuming this is real life and not fantasy.....

Anyways, I think it's pretty weak to have one person be the MVP and another win Offensive POY (like last year with Rodgers/Brees)....seems like a cheap excuse to give both players an award. If you're the best MVP, and you're a QB or RB, how are you NOT offensive player of the year as well? Makes no sense.

Anyways, if I voted, I would vote like this.

MVP - Peyton Manning

Offensive POY - Peyton Manning

Offensive Rookie of the year - Robert Griffin III

Defensive POY - JJ Watt

Defensive Rookie of the year - Bobby Wagner

Coach of the Year - Chuck Pagano/Bruce Arians

Comeback Player - Peyton Manning

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm assuming this is real life and not fantasy.....

Anyways, I think it's pretty weak to have one person be the MVP and another win Offensive POY (like last year with Rodgers/Brees)....seems like a cheap excuse to give both players an award. If you're the best MVP, and you're a QB or RB, how are you NOT offensive player of the year as well? Makes no sense.

Anyways, if I voted, I would vote like this.

MVP - Peyton Manning

Offensive POY - Peyton Manning

Offensive Rookie of the year - Robert Griffin III

Defensive POY - JJ Watt

Defensive Rookie of the year - Bobby Wagner

Coach of the Year - Chuck Pagano/Bruce Arians

Comeback Player - Peyton Manning

Couldn't agree more with the part in bold, makes no sense and it is a way for voters to hedge their bets. At the same time, I don't think Pagano should be eligible for coach of the year, it should be Bruce Arians.

MVP - Adrien Peterson

OPOY - Adrien Peterson

ROY - RGIII

DMVP - Von Miller

COY - Bruce Arians (Jeff Fisher 2nd)

DROY - Luke Keuchly

Comeback Player - Adrien Peterson, what he is doing is that insane

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I see it a little differently. I think MVP is the person that is most valuable to their team; the single person who makes their team better more then any other player makes their team better. Peyton Manning is awesome, but the Bronco's won a playoff game with Tebow. He adds wins, but not as many wins as someone like AP adds to the Vikings. With no AP and Percy out, the Vikings might not even have 3 wins...

That's how I would justify those awards going to two different players.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.