Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

NYSportsfan24

Edwin Encarnacion 2013 Outlook

390 posts in this topic

What are we expecting in 2013? Does anyone expeact a repeat of last years gaudy numbers?

I have a feeling he will be overvalued.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What are we expecting in 2013? Does anyone expeact a repeat of last years gaudy numbers?

I have a feeling he will be overvalued.

I think he will hit over 30 homers again, and get a decent amount of RBIs in that new lineup. I don't think he will get the double digit steals again. I also think the average will stay around the same as long as he can keep taking more walks like he did last year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It doesnt matter in my league because of course some dude got him for a $1 last year, but Im just not a buyer on him at all, I need to see one more year. In my 1B rankings, I think I have him around the 9-12 Tier.

Im not taking him ahead of: Pujols, Fielder, Votto, AGon, and Goldy.

I would probably lean towards Teixeira, Trumbo, Butler over him.

He would for me be in the Hosmer, Freeman, Davis group and probably a coin flip at best with those guys.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

your first 5 yes. butler yes. might be questionable for teixeira. now what I meant is to be able to get someone like him to perform where people go him last year this year.

so many guys people gave up on or figured they were not going to be consistent for a full season and be good actually did and were not even big name guys ever or were hyped.

encarnacion

willingham

kubel

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

your first 5 yes. butler yes. might be questionable for teixeira. now what I meant is to be able to get someone like him to perform where people go him last year this year.

so many guys people gave up on or figured they were not going to be consistent for a full season and be good actually did and were not even big name guys ever or were hyped.

encarnacion

willingham

kubel

I hear what you are saying you wanna find the next Encarnacion, someone who has been around a while year in year out same numbers then boom...breakout big time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

E5 has always had the power, but as far as his breakout last year he took a whole new (and obviously improved) approach with his swing. The first thought after a 42 HR season is to expect some regression, but with this Toronto lineup looking nasty, I'm thinking he can still deliver top 4-6 1B numbers pretty easily. I'm hoping they can primarily DH him to keep him fresh and to get his bat in the lineup everyday. Any steals he throws in is just gravy.

Projection: .275, 95 R, 36 HR, 105 RBI, 10 SB with upside for another .280+ 40+ HR season (and elite counting stats)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It doesnt matter in my league because of course some dude got him for a $1 last year, but Im just not a buyer on him at all, I need to see one more year. In my 1B rankings, I think I have him around the 9-12 Tier.

Im not taking him ahead of: Pujols, Fielder, Votto, AGon, and Goldy.

I would probably lean towards Teixeira, Trumbo, Butler over him.

He would for me be in the Hosmer, Freeman, Davis group and probably a coin flip at best with those guys.

Goldy as in Paul Goldschmidt? You would seriously pass on Edwin to take Goldschmidt?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm in the minority I guess for not liking this guy. Maybe he pulled a full Bautista. Or, he's gonna be what he was for years prior. A streak power hitter that annoys more that brings smiles.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sorry I just can't see taking a young player who hit 20 HR's last year over a guy in his prime who broke through for 42 HR last year. I'm not saying Goldy won't improve as he most certainly will. But Edwin put it all together last year. I don't see an arguement for Goldy. But I'd be interested to hear one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Anyone else concerned the new testing could nab him? Rumors have followed this guy...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It doesnt matter in my league because of course some dude got him for a $1 last year, but Im just not a buyer on him at all, I need to see one more year. In my 1B rankings, I think I have him around the 9-12 Tier.

Im not taking him ahead of: Pujols, Fielder, Votto, AGon, and Goldy.

I would probably lean towards Teixeira, Trumbo, Butler over him.

He would for me be in the Hosmer, Freeman, Davis group and probably a coin flip at best with those guys.

Goldy as in Paul Goldschmidt? You would seriously pass on Edwin to take Goldschmidt?

Absolutely I would pass on Encarnacion...he is going to be the next Richard Hidalgo, remember when he hit 40HR and 120RBI...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It doesnt matter in my league because of course some dude got him for a $1 last year, but Im just not a buyer on him at all, I need to see one more year. In my 1B rankings, I think I have him around the 9-12 Tier.

Im not taking him ahead of: Pujols, Fielder, Votto, AGon, and Goldy.

I would probably lean towards Teixeira, Trumbo, Butler over him.

He would for me be in the Hosmer, Freeman, Davis group and probably a coin flip at best with those guys.

Goldy as in Paul Goldschmidt? You would seriously pass on Edwin to take Goldschmidt?

Absolutely I would pass on Encarnacion...he is going to be the next Richard Hidalgo, remember when he hit 40HR and 120RBI...

You say that based on what exactly? Gut feeling? Because every metric I've checked says his breakout is for real and backed by some history of EE possessing that skill in the past.

He obviously has big power and his plate approach is very good for a slugger. Contact rates have been 83, 84, 83 last 3 seasons (Cano is an 86). His BB rates really improved last season that is often a sign of a true breakout, and it improved as the season progressed partially due to J Bau's injury but that is also a very good sign. He also hits a ton of fly balls which should ensure 30+ HR. Injuries have been one of this biggest draw backs, but playing 1B/DH has really helped there.

I just hope there are more people who are willing to discount last season so I can snag him in the 3rd. He is probably a 2nd round value but being a 1B only now there is very little profit to be made there, I'd love him in the 3rd.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It doesnt matter in my league because of course some dude got him for a $1 last year, but Im just not a buyer on him at all, I need to see one more year. In my 1B rankings, I think I have him around the 9-12 Tier.

Im not taking him ahead of: Pujols, Fielder, Votto, AGon, and Goldy.

I would probably lean towards Teixeira, Trumbo, Butler over him.

He would for me be in the Hosmer, Freeman, Davis group and probably a coin flip at best with those guys.

Goldy as in Paul Goldschmidt? You would seriously pass on Edwin to take Goldschmidt?

Absolutely I would pass on Encarnacion...he is going to be the next Richard Hidalgo, remember when he hit 40HR and 120RBI...

You say that based on what exactly? Gut feeling? Because every metric I've checked says his breakout is for real and backed by some history of EE possessing that skill in the past.

He obviously has big power and his plate approach is very good for a slugger. Contact rates have been 83, 84, 83 last 3 seasons (Cano is an 86). His BB rates really improved last season that is often a sign of a true breakout, and it improved as the season progressed partially due to J Bau's injury but that is also a very good sign. He also hits a ton of fly balls which should ensure 30+ HR. Injuries have been one of this biggest draw backs, but playing 1B/DH has really helped there.

I just hope there are more people who are willing to discount last season so I can snag him in the 3rd. He is probably a 2nd round value but being a 1B only now there is very little profit to be made there, I'd love him in the 3rd.

And how would those metrics be different than say the numbers put up by Richard Hidalgo in his 44HR season or Brady Anderson in his 50HR season. Look he had a great year and was locked in but perhaps its health issues or the fact I just dont see him as a year in year out 30+ HR guy but maybe its just the skeptic in me, Im not buying Chase Headley, RA Dickey, Mike Trout 30HR power either...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It doesnt matter in my league because of course some dude got him for a $1 last year, but Im just not a buyer on him at all, I need to see one more year. In my 1B rankings, I think I have him around the 9-12 Tier.

Im not taking him ahead of: Pujols, Fielder, Votto, AGon, and Goldy.

I would probably lean towards Teixeira, Trumbo, Butler over him.

He would for me be in the Hosmer, Freeman, Davis group and probably a coin flip at best with those guys.

Goldy as in Paul Goldschmidt? You would seriously pass on Edwin to take Goldschmidt?

Absolutely I would pass on Encarnacion...he is going to be the next Richard Hidalgo, remember when he hit 40HR and 120RBI...

You say that based on what exactly? Gut feeling? Because every metric I've checked says his breakout is for real and backed by some history of EE possessing that skill in the past.

He obviously has big power and his plate approach is very good for a slugger. Contact rates have been 83, 84, 83 last 3 seasons (Cano is an 86). His BB rates really improved last season that is often a sign of a true breakout, and it improved as the season progressed partially due to J Bau's injury but that is also a very good sign. He also hits a ton of fly balls which should ensure 30+ HR. Injuries have been one of this biggest draw backs, but playing 1B/DH has really helped there.

I just hope there are more people who are willing to discount last season so I can snag him in the 3rd. He is probably a 2nd round value but being a 1B only now there is very little profit to be made there, I'd love him in the 3rd.

And how would those metrics be different than say the numbers put up by Richard Hidalgo in his 44HR season or Brady Anderson in his 50HR season. Look he had a great year and was locked in but perhaps its health issues or the fact I just dont see him as a year in year out 30+ HR guy but maybe its just the skeptic in me, Im not buying Chase Headley, RA Dickey, Mike Trout 30HR power either...

I'd agree with those, Trout and Headley each had 27% HR/FB rates in the 2nd half last season. That ridiculous number is obviously not sustainable. EE was a consistent 18/19% all season, which I could see dropping back to a 16/17 next season, which could still net him 35 HR.

In regards to Dickey he's been a similar pitcher for 3 years now except one scorching hot stretch of games early last season, I'm going to use what he did in the 2nd half as a baseline for this season, except cut back his SO totals some.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Keep in mind this guy was a pretty highly regarded prospect. It took him a while to figure it out...but he's clearly got it now. Also bear in mind...it wasn't just 2012. He also tore it up in the 2nd half of 2011, in addition to showing flashes of brilliance prior. The break out is for real.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It doesnt matter in my league because of course some dude got him for a $1 last year, but Im just not a buyer on him at all, I need to see one more year. In my 1B rankings, I think I have him around the 9-12 Tier.

Im not taking him ahead of: Pujols, Fielder, Votto, AGon, and Goldy.

I would probably lean towards Teixeira, Trumbo, Butler over him.

He would for me be in the Hosmer, Freeman, Davis group and probably a coin flip at best with those guys.

Goldy as in Paul Goldschmidt? You would seriously pass on Edwin to take Goldschmidt?

Absolutely I would pass on Encarnacion...he is going to be the next Richard Hidalgo, remember when he hit 40HR and 120RBI...

You say that based on what exactly? Gut feeling? Because every metric I've checked says his breakout is for real and backed by some history of EE possessing that skill in the past.

He obviously has big power and his plate approach is very good for a slugger. Contact rates have been 83, 84, 83 last 3 seasons (Cano is an 86). His BB rates really improved last season that is often a sign of a true breakout, and it improved as the season progressed partially due to J Bau's injury but that is also a very good sign. He also hits a ton of fly balls which should ensure 30+ HR. Injuries have been one of this biggest draw backs, but playing 1B/DH has really helped there.

I just hope there are more people who are willing to discount last season so I can snag him in the 3rd. He is probably a 2nd round value but being a 1B only now there is very little profit to be made there, I'd love him in the 3rd.

And how would those metrics be different than say the numbers put up by Richard Hidalgo in his 44HR season or Brady Anderson in his 50HR season. Look he had a great year and was locked in but perhaps its health issues or the fact I just dont see him as a year in year out 30+ HR guy but maybe its just the skeptic in me, Im not buying Chase Headley, RA Dickey, Mike Trout 30HR power either...

I could see dickey hitting 30 bombs...

2 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It doesnt matter in my league because of course some dude got him for a $1 last year, but Im just not a buyer on him at all, I need to see one more year. In my 1B rankings, I think I have him around the 9-12 Tier.

Im not taking him ahead of: Pujols, Fielder, Votto, AGon, and Goldy.

I would probably lean towards Teixeira, Trumbo, Butler over him.

He would for me be in the Hosmer, Freeman, Davis group and probably a coin flip at best with those guys.

Goldy as in Paul Goldschmidt? You would seriously pass on Edwin to take Goldschmidt?

Absolutely I would pass on Encarnacion...he is going to be the next Richard Hidalgo, remember when he hit 40HR and 120RBI...

You say that based on what exactly? Gut feeling? Because every metric I've checked says his breakout is for real and backed by some history of EE possessing that skill in the past.

He obviously has big power and his plate approach is very good for a slugger. Contact rates have been 83, 84, 83 last 3 seasons (Cano is an 86). His BB rates really improved last season that is often a sign of a true breakout, and it improved as the season progressed partially due to J Bau's injury but that is also a very good sign. He also hits a ton of fly balls which should ensure 30+ HR. Injuries have been one of this biggest draw backs, but playing 1B/DH has really helped there.

I just hope there are more people who are willing to discount last season so I can snag him in the 3rd. He is probably a 2nd round value but being a 1B only now there is very little profit to be made there, I'd love him in the 3rd.

And how would those metrics be different than say the numbers put up by Richard Hidalgo in his 44HR season or Brady Anderson in his 50HR season. Look he had a great year and was locked in but perhaps its health issues or the fact I just dont see him as a year in year out 30+ HR guy but maybe its just the skeptic in me, Im not buying Chase Headley, RA Dickey, Mike Trout 30HR power either...

I could see dickey hitting 30 bombs...

LOL the Rogers Centre is pretty good for right handed power!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

too bad he got traded to the AL so we will never know what could have been... :(

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It doesnt matter in my league because of course some dude got him for a $1 last year, but Im just not a buyer on him at all, I need to see one more year. In my 1B rankings, I think I have him around the 9-12 Tier.

Im not taking him ahead of: Pujols, Fielder, Votto, AGon, and Goldy.

I would probably lean towards Teixeira, Trumbo, Butler over him.

He would for me be in the Hosmer, Freeman, Davis group and probably a coin flip at best with those guys.

Goldy as in Paul Goldschmidt? You would seriously pass on Edwin to take Goldschmidt?

Absolutely I would pass on Encarnacion...he is going to be the next Richard Hidalgo, remember when he hit 40HR and 120RBI...

You say that based on what exactly? Gut feeling? Because every metric I've checked says his breakout is for real and backed by some history of EE possessing that skill in the past.

He obviously has big power and his plate approach is very good for a slugger. Contact rates have been 83, 84, 83 last 3 seasons (Cano is an 86). His BB rates really improved last season that is often a sign of a true breakout, and it improved as the season progressed partially due to J Bau's injury but that is also a very good sign. He also hits a ton of fly balls which should ensure 30+ HR. Injuries have been one of this biggest draw backs, but playing 1B/DH has really helped there.

I just hope there are more people who are willing to discount last season so I can snag him in the 3rd. He is probably a 2nd round value but being a 1B only now there is very little profit to be made there, I'd love him in the 3rd.

And how would those metrics be different than say the numbers put up by Richard Hidalgo in his 44HR season or Brady Anderson in his 50HR season. Look he had a great year and was locked in but perhaps its health issues or the fact I just dont see him as a year in year out 30+ HR guy but maybe its just the skeptic in me, Im not buying Chase Headley, RA Dickey, Mike Trout 30HR power either...

I could see dickey hitting 30 bombs...

It reads wrong, kind of like the golf headline this week in rotoworld "Gay last man standing in Humana shootout". If you arent a golf fan, you probably think that headline is talking about another random act of gun violence.

It was Trout 30 bomb power I wasnt buying.

2 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

didn't people say the same things about Bautista? meaning many passed on him following his first great season? at least Encar had some ok seasons prior to exploding...

There's no reason why he can't put up 30 and 90, especially with Melky and Reyes in that lineup

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

didn't people say the same things about Bautista? meaning many passed on him following his first great season? at least Encar had some ok seasons prior to exploding...

There's no reason why he can't put up 30 and 90, especially with Melky and Reyes in that lineup

Especially since his peripherals matched his production. He also hit .280 with a BABIP of around .260 so he could even improve on that area this year. I don't think he will hit 40 plus homers again but 30 and 90 should be a fair projection with upside.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.