Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

AnonymousRob

Bartolo Colon 2013 Outlook

260 posts in this topic

Alright, let's say this first - standard size leagues might stream this guy a few times but for the most part he's going appeal to those in deep leagues and/or AL only. But I think there's some value here for those in such settings. There have been a few posts in this forum over the past couple months which seem to completely dismiss the guy. And instead of addressing those elsewhere, I figured we'd tackle it head on in here. From another thread:

But let's get some facts straight. Colon first off hasn't pitched a full season in the bigs since 2005. He will be 40 in May. His BABIP was below his career average and HR/FB below his career average. Now they weren't entirely out of line with his career averages but at the same time the guy is 40 and something is going to eventually give.

Can Colon post a 3.43 ERA over a full season? Chances are extremely slim. Colon could very well be a disaster next year. A hardcore regression is the most likely scenario in this case. The guy is 40, by no means was he dominating, and has proven to be injury prone throughout his career.

He probably won't last an entire year. But expecting 150 innings out of the guy (with the potential for more) isn't unreasonable. He's done that each of the past two seasons.

Yes, he's old by baseball standards. He was old last year when he pitched 152 innings and went 10-9 with a 3.43 era. Maybe he'll fall off a cliff due to his age. Maybe he'll fall off a cliff without taking testosterone. Both are possible. But if he flops, so what? You cut the last player drafted? The cost is absurdly low.

His career babip is 292. Last year it was 286. That's right in line with career numbers. His hr/fb rate for his career is 10.8%. Last year it was 9.1%. Pitching in Oakland has its benefits for a pitcher. Giving up fewer home runs is one of those benefits.

His era was under his fip/xfip but looking at his career as a whole, he's generally been able to pitch better than the peripherals.

He gave up slightly fewer line drives than his career norms (18% vs. 19.4%). He had more groundballs since 2002.

Hitters did swing and miss at a lower rate than ever before. Last year he had a career high in guys swinging at pitches out of the strike zone (though 2007 and 2011 were close to last year's numbers). He also gave up a career high contact rate.

He's clearly not the same pitcher he once was. But he's not trying to be the same pitcher he once was. It's quite interesting, really. He's throwing his two seam more than ever and his 4 seam less than ever. He's relying on what some scouts in 2011 were calling a "wicked" two seam and just pitching to contact. And it's working. It's causing weak grounders and pop ups.

He'll fall off a cliff at some point. That point may come this year. But for a guy who can be had as your very last pick, 150 innings of a 4 era and a 1.20 whip isn't anything to sneeze at. If Tim Hudson is a guy on your radar, Colon should be as well. Only Hudson has an ADP of 41st pitcher while Bartolo is unranked.

Unsexy value is still value.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If I were in an AL only league, he would for sure be on my undervalued list. Guys love sexy and upside, he is neither.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Going into last year, there were 3 SP who met the requirements to be listed as both Extreme Flyball (>36% FB & <2.9 BB/9) and Extreme Groundball (>44% GB & >7.0 K/9) pitchers, this was the list...

David Price

Yovani Gallardo

Bartolo Colon

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You draft Colon I'll draft Straily. We will revist this come season's end.

Straily is going to fight it out with AJ Griffin for the #5 spot. Colon is suspended the first 5 games of the year but aside from that has earned a spot in the rotation. Maybe he'll lose it during the year. But he earned it with his performance last year. It seems you were either deliberately misleading people by mentioning his numbers or you simply weren't overly familiar with what he did. Which would be understandable - if he weren't pitching for my team I likely wouldn't look very closely.

Straily is an elite talent. I've never denied that. I do not appreciate you claiming the opposite. I fired up his thread last year when he was called up. I've followed Fish On and others when they were watching him in the minors. He'll definitely get a shot this year either from injury and/or trades.

I'm mentioning how undervalued Colon is not because it's "a triggered emotional response". I'm dealing with actual facts and statistics. I noticed you and some other posters don't seem to value him at all. When I see a player is getting little respect, that signals he may be a good player to draft. I didn't mention you in the OP because this thread was about Bartolo Colon. Not your obsession with comparing the two and claiming Straily is getting cheated out of a job for political or financial reasons. If you would like to make a counter point I would love to see it. This time of year folks tend to bring more beef behind their arguments rather than rely on hyperbolic statements. I showed the peripherals behind his numbers, listed his ADP, and compared him to another player that is often drafted (Hudson) despite the massive ADP differential. I look forward to hearing your argument if you choose to bring one.

There are definitely concerns with any player once they reach a certain age. There are also concerns with a guy who gets busted for PED's. He may fall off a cliff. But he may also do what he's done the past two seasons. And at his current ADP (too low to rank), it's well worth the gamble to find out.

If Straily starts in the minors, it's because he couldn't beat out AJ Griffin. Not because this is "in all honesty is more of a political money saving strategy and not because he is less skillful than Colon." Even though last year's numbers show Colon was better than Straily. Will Straily be better than Colon in a few years? Of course. But the A's are dealing with the here and now. They won their division last year and are trying to contend for the playoffs once more.

Colon has earned his spot in the rotation. He pitched well last year. He's a good gamble in certain leagues this year. You claiming a person can draft either Colon or Straily is a bizarre strawman at best. Colon is an unsexy name. Colon has limited upside. But he's still being undervalued. If he can repeat last year's numbers, he'd be an asset for a lot of teams.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My whole point was (that you're blowing out of proportion) was that Straily is by no means blockes by Colon at this point in his career.

But seriously if Colon doesn't open the season of I highly doubt that he'll be in the rotation unless there's an injury. There is just too much talent in that rotation.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here's a question I have about Colon and maybe someone will have some insight or opinion. I realize that he is suspended the first 5 games of the season, do you think that the A's 6th game of the season (4/6) he will actually get the start, or will it be the second time around in the rotation that he will get a start?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Hidden by The Harsh, April 5, 2013 - No reason given · Report post

Stream vs. the Stros?

Share this post


Link to post

Posted · Hidden by The Harsh, April 5, 2013 - No reason given · Report post

Stream vs. the Stros?

The answer to that question is always yes

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post

Posted · Hidden by The Harsh, April 5, 2013 - No reason given · Report post

Stream vs. the Stros?

The answer to that question is always yes

Touche.

Share this post


Link to post

I would consider it but he's one of the few pitchers out there that makes me hesitant even against the disastros. He was horrible in the spring IIRCI. He also had like the lowest swinging strike rate in the league last year too, he literally just pumps in 88 MPH fastballs every pitch.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I really, really thought about starting him against Houston. I still could be swayed, I suppose. But the cliff is coming at some point...

And now that we know he's off the juice...

tumblr_lysozaPyBs1r4bl01o1_500.gif

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I really, really thought about starting him against Houston. I still could be swayed, I suppose. But the cliff is coming at some point...

And now that we know he's off the juice...

tumblr_lysozaPyBs1r4bl01o1_500.gif

I feel the same way. Just can't trust Staypuft Marshmellow Man to help me out this week, not after how his recent pitching has looked.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am starting him with confidence today. He is pitching to keep a spot in the rotation and is facing The Kstros. Plus it is early so fatigue shouldn't be an issue. I could see him getting 10 Ks in 7 innings. I am also starting Bud Norris so hopefully it is a low scoring game.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not over-thinking this one - running him out with confidence versus these sad sacks...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have no doubt the K-seekers will get Ks. He struck out 22 in 20 IP this spring, and the Astros are windmills.

BUT… those Ks came with a 6.30 ERA and a 1.60 WHIP. It's ST though - who knows...

Just feel like the Astros are going to hit at some point… maybe not consistently, but someone's going to get knocked around when we're least expecting it...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Cant believe they sent Straily down for this fat, old juicer. Heres hoping he gets rocked his first couple starts and gives way to Straily.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

picked up colon in h2h and starting him and keeping straily in keeper league (N/A Spot on Yahoo)...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I streamed him. Granted I have a major lead in ERA and am trying to catch my opponent in K's, figured if there was anyone to throw tubby, it was the Astros.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You'd be crazy not to throw him out against the Astros. Last night one of their dudes swung at a pitch that was already in the catcher's mitt (not kidding - worst swing by an MLB player I've ever witnessed)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Unreal, stupid crawford boxes. Castro hits a 290 foot home run. SMH.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1 strikeout against the Astros = Deathblow

He doesn't really throw out pitches (just fastballs), so that's not too surprising. I watched a game against the Angels last year where he threw like 33 straight fastballs (and actually won that game).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How does he only have 2 K's? Figured only Beavan would struggle to strikeout the Astros.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.