Forgot your password?
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.
KingBax, February 15, 2013 in Bench Coach Help Forum
Kinsler because I like having the best player in the deal. Only way I'd be swayed is if it's a dynasty league and you need to keep a 2B every year (a position switch for Kinsler could be in the cards)
Kinsler wins. Usually in a 2 for 1, you want the best player. Kubel is replaceable and Altuve is not as good as Kinsler is.
If it is the team in signature you lose big time. You wouldn't be keeping either player you get back in return.
If you can keep both players I might do the trade as Kubal would have good value for you and Altuve would be a fairly good replacement for Kinsler.
I like Altuve, but Kubel is barely even a starter in a 20-team, 3 OF setup, not sure why the person with Kinsler would even be considering this.
I was thinking of keeping Altuve, and trading Kubel/Ellsbury/Cruz for a top 10 player... Thanks for the help.
No registered users viewing this page.