Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

octapuss

Adam Dunn 2013 Outlook

345 posts in this topic

Funny. Last year there was 33 pages dedicated to this lug. This year the thread hasnt even been started. I guess thats what you get when you hit 41 HR and strikeout 222 times.

What to do with this guy? Yes he will hit you a bunch of bombs. Yes he will strike out a ton. If it is a roto league you can kind of stomach it. If it is a head to head league, any given week he can kill ya. Bench material. Are you going to roster him?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Totally disagree Dunn has value, his batting average is a killer either way, roto or H2H.

His OPS for the last 2 1/2 seasons combined is below league-average, even with 2 38+ HR seasons.

His K rate and low contact rate make him unrosterable.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hmmm. Dunn hit 41 hrs and strikes out a ton. Agree. But comes much cheaper a less deep spot than somebody that goes much higher and plays a deeper spot. Curtis Granderson. When it comes to standard 5x5 AL only leagues auction or snake. Is CG really worth that much more or worth taking that much earlier than Dunn? I don't think he is .

I happen to think Dunn bounces back in BA this year and hits more in the .250 range. I'll take 38-40/90-100 from a corner spot much later.

Would I own Dunn? If I still have a spot later yes. Would I own Granderson ? Yes but no way I grab him early as his ADP. I bid him up and let somebody else pay.

I realize we are talking about Dunn but wanted to use CG to compare. Mark Reynolds is another thats grabbed way to early because he plays third base. Is he better than Dunn?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dunn had his highest HR/FB rate of his career, over 29%. Does he repeat that?

His composite BA projection between Steamer, Bill James, Oliver and Zips is about .200 over 500 or so AB.

That's 100 total hits to draw 40 HR from. Can he do that?

What if he only hits 32 HR? At least Granderson chips in a few steals, Dunn has 2 total in 4 seasons.

And the BA drain, if it takes about .265 to finish in the top half of your roto league, you need 1325 hits over 5000 AB to bat to generate that average. You'll need 1225 hits out of your other 4500 AB to compensate for Dunn. That means everybody else has to hit .273 combined. He's an 8 point AVG drain by himself. .273 wins most leagues in AVG.

I'm not a buyer.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Funny. Last year there was 33 pages dedicated to this lug. This year the thread hasnt even been started. I guess thats what you get when you hit 41 HR and strikeout 222 times.

What to do with this guy? Yes he will hit you a bunch of bombs. Yes he will strike out a ton. If it is a roto league you can kind of stomach it. If it is a head to head league, any given week he can kill ya. Bench material. Are you going to roster him?

No way in hell.......

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dunn had his highest HR/FB rate of his career, over 29%. Does he repeat that?

His composite BA projection between Steamer, Bill James, Oliver and Zips is about .200 over 500 or so AB.

That's 100 total hits to draw 40 HR from. Can he do that?

What if he only hits 32 HR? At least Granderson chips in a few steals, Dunn has 2 total in 4 seasons.

And the BA drain, if it takes about .265 to finish in the top half of your roto league, you need 1325 hits over 5000 AB to bat to generate that average. You'll need 1225 hits out of your other 4500 AB to compensate for Dunn. That means everybody else has to hit .273 combined. He's an 8 point AVG drain by himself. .273 wins most leagues in AVG.

I'm not a buyer.

I`m not as skeptical of his HR rate. He hits in a bandbox. Pop ups go for HRs in that stadium. Sabermetrics do not take into account hitting environment. Dunn is fortunate enough to hit half his games in Comisky Park-US Celleur-Whatever the F its called now-Park. In OBP leagues the guy has value. .333 OBP is not stellar, but its not a killer either. In an average league I would not roster him though. His BA in baseball, is like what Dwight Howards FTs are for someone who plays fantasy basketball. Very hard to overcome that .200 clip in a roto league and still maintain a decent point total in average in a league.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'll be picking him around the 12th and loving it. My league counts BB, so between his HRs and BBs, he's well worth rostering.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Depends on your team makeup and scoring system. In most settings I can't get on board with this guy being an overall asset to an owner. The home runs are great but it gets awfully ugly after that. If you go for pitching early or for some other reason end up with a lot of power starved slap hitters, Dunn would be a godsend for your team. Aside from that? Pass.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dunn had his highest HR/FB rate of his career, over 29%. Does he repeat that?

His composite BA projection between Steamer, Bill James, Oliver and Zips is about .200 over 500 or so AB.

That's 100 total hits to draw 40 HR from. Can he do that?

What if he only hits 32 HR? At least Granderson chips in a few steals, Dunn has 2 total in 4 seasons.

And the BA drain, if it takes about .265 to finish in the top half of your roto league, you need 1325 hits over 5000 AB to bat to generate that average. You'll need 1225 hits out of your other 4500 AB to compensate for Dunn. That means everybody else has to hit .273 combined. He's an 8 point AVG drain by himself. .273 wins most leagues in AVG.

I'm not a buyer.

Sure Granderson pitches in a few steals. But where is he being drafted in comparison to Dunn ? What player could you get in that spot if you didn't draft Granderson there? And still be able to get Dunn and his 35 hrs later.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You know what you're getting with Dunn. A tons of bombs, walks and strikeouts. Take it or leave it

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I drafted him after i had trout/Ichiro/S.Perez/Jones/Andrus/Altuve on my team...hoping he doesnt kill my overall average but i needed pop.....i might try to bench him on heavy lefty weeks as he hit a robust .211 against righties!....smokin!!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Is there any way he bounces back to some degree in average? Before the last couple years he would usually hit .260 or something, now the dude can barely keep it above .200.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Is there any way he bounces back to some degree in average? Before the last couple years he would usually hit .260 or something, now the dude can barely keep it above .200.

Hit .260 once in his career, it was his career year 2004. I lived in Cincinnati and saw him every day that summer. He was something to marvel at then.

Sister Christian, what's your price for flight

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Scooped him up in the 15th round!!! Our league has OBP to, so his horrible average wont kill my squad this year, very very happy with the value here.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Scooped him up in the 15th round!!! Our league has OBP to, so his horrible average wont kill my squad this year, very very happy with the value here.

Extremely late, especially if OBP is REPLACING average.

90-40-90 .333

Top 10 1B easily in that format

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm going to roster Dunn as long as I can. I will play him only when I really like the matchup. Balance out the walks category hopefully. It would be nice if he has a decent April (he typically starts strong) and could draw some kind of value or interest

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I pretty much end up with this guy every year ... He fell so far in my 14 teamer I had to grab him

Pencil him in for 35-40HR or have I missed something?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Is there any way he bounces back to some degree in average? Before the last couple years he would usually hit .260 or something, now the dude can barely keep it above .200.

Hit .260 once in his career, it was his career year 2004. I lived in Cincinnati and saw him every day that summer. He was something to marvel at then.

Sister Christian, what's your price for flight

Nah, he hit .260+ in 2004, 2007, 2009, and 2010. He then had that albatross year of 2011 and then last year... 09/10 he was pretty valuable though because he was 40/100 while not killing your average, and that's only 2 seasons ago. But his strikeout rate is steadily increasing since then, I don't think there's much if any chance he can hit close to that again.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Through the first 2/3rds (or so) of 2012 Dunn was doing quite well and had around a .900 OPS (or so) before going into a horrific slump to finish the season.

It was a sustained enough stretch to suggest that he might have something left in the tank.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

BOOM!!!

Oh wait, he's on my bench. :(

Facing a righty, I try to start him every game. It's a tough choice having him in a weekly points format, I started him over Goldy because he was facing a majority of righties this week.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Nice game today. 2 for 3 with a bomb, walk, and 2 runs scored. He's startable against right handers every game.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites