Recommended Posts

11 minutes ago, Rolling Thunder said:

 

Feel free read to my post that way, especially if fuels your take on the McKinnon signing.  When enough returns are in (we won't need the whole season), I will explain what you missed (hint, it's already laid out in the McKinnon thread).

 

In the meantime though, don't be deterred (not that I believe you ever would be).  Last off-season's "Gurley is a JAG, scrub, etc." club had its cock-sure spokesperson too (you can visit the early pages of the 2017 Gurley thread to find out who that was).  That spokesperson was certain as well that no change of circumstance could boost that player's fortunes. This off-sason, it is great that the "McKinnon is a JAG, scrub etc." club now has it's immodest spokesperson.  Makes the inevitable post-mortem so much easier and fun.

 

 

 

 

 

Again, this is NOT the same as Gurley. 

 

We're talking about a 26 year old RB here who has never put up top 10 numbers. He has a career 4.0 YPC, and has more than ample opportunity to take hold of the Viking's lead back role on multiple occasions. 

 

He's also gone to a pretty average offense in my opinion. There's a lot of hype around Jimmy G, but I'm not a fan of the offensive talent. Garçon, Goodwin, Kittle, McKinnon. Very uninspiring group of players. 

 

The only way McK returns value on his ADP is if he has 60+ receptions. Still...I doubt the rushing yards and TDs are there to back this up. 

 

You can feel free to quote me when the dust settles if that's your thing. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)
39 minutes ago, Experienced Rookie said:

He's also gone to a pretty average offense in my opinion. There's a lot of hype around Jimmy G, but I'm not a fan of the offensive talent. Garçon, Goodwin, Kittle, McKinnon. Very uninspiring group of players. 

 

How is it that that uninspiring group sans Garcon, and with Jimmy G. fresh off the bus, hung 44 pts on the 2nd best D in week 16 in a game JAX had to win?  The answer will lead you to new, greener pastures.

 

For some reason, you're reluctant to scratch below the surface on this one.  That's fine.  Don't let me inject any doubt into your normally self-sure position.  Once  a JAG or scrub, always a JAG or scrub, right?

 

In any event, the discussion is likely to be far more interesting and focused when the returns are in (for both the offense and the player).

 

Edited by Rolling Thunder
  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

These Roto reports coming out for Jones and Booker are really changing the outlook for these rookies 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, boshtrich17 said:

These Roto reports coming out for Jones and Booker are really changing the outlook for these rookies 

It's June. I bet these situations look different in August. I'd be shocked if Barber forces his way into the picture and Booker is bad, Freeman should emerge. Of course, the rookies are unproven too. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, boshtrich17 said:

These Roto reports coming out for Jones and Booker are really changing the outlook for these rookies 

It's really all conjecture at this point.  They like Barber, and he played surprisingly well last year for a stretch.  I wouldn't expect the team to immediately come out and anoint Jones the three-down role before pads are even put on.  Bottom line, they took him with high draft capital to be their answer at the position.  It's really up to him at this point to put it all together.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
11 hours ago, SharkSwimmer said:

If by JStew Vol II you mean Aliens from 1986, a sequal that was better than the original.

I don't know how this post got passed me. 

 

Alien and Aliens are in my top 10 favorite films of all time. 

 

While Aliens is one of the best action movies ever made, the original film is still more compelling IMO. 

 

I hate that Jstew and CJ Anderson have now been compared to them. 

  • Haha 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, JoeJoe88 said:

It's really all conjecture at this point.  They like Barber, and he played surprisingly well last year for a stretch.  I wouldn't expect the team to immediately come out and anoint Jones the three-down role before pads are even put on.  Bottom line, they took him with high draft capital to be their answer at the position.  It's really up to him at this point to put it all together.

 

Tampa's Director of Player Personnel John Spytek joined GMF this morning.  He talked up Jones alot.  Didn't mention Barber once.  If Barber has been surprising folks, I would expect a brief mention, at least.  Curious.

 

Edited by Rolling Thunder

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My top 20 in standard:

 

1. Elliot

2. Johnson

3. Bell

4. Gurley

5. Barkley

6. Kamara

7. Fournette

8. Cook

9. Gordon

10. Hunt

11. Howard

12. Shady

13. Freeman

14. Mixon

15. Penny

16. Guice

17. CMC

18. Henry

19. McKinnon

20. Miller

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Gohawks said:

My top 20 in standard:

 

1. Elliot

2. Johnson

3. Bell

4. Gurley

5. Barkley

6. Kamara

7. Fournette

8. Cook

9. Gordon

10. Hunt

11. Howard

12. Shady

13. Freeman

14. Mixon

15. Penny

16. Guice

17. CMC

18. Henry

19. McKinnon

20. Miller


Good list... you're bucking a lot of the traditional "expert" thought this year. 

Why do you think Elliot over Johnson, Bell, Gurley?

Also, why McCaffrey under Mixon, Penny, Guice?

Edited by ponza88

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
14 hours ago, Experienced Rookie said:

I don't know how this post got passed me. 

 

Alien and Aliens are in my top 10 favorite films of all time. 

 

While Aliens is one of the best action movies ever made, the original film is still more compelling IMO. 

 

I hate that Jstew and CJ Anderson have now been compared to them. 

Maybe it should be Breakin' 2: Electric Boogaloo, instead.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, ponza88 said:


Good list... you're bucking a lot of the traditional "expert" thought this year. 

Why do you think Elliot over Johnson, Bell, Gurley?

Also, why McCaffrey under Mixon, Penny, Guice?

Elliot is the safest option out of all of them. It’s really difficult to find any concern. Bell has been run into the ground and Johnson has the entire offense around him a question. With Gurley, it just seems like last season was an anomaly for the offense. It’s not that the offense isn’t good but rather they’re not first overall good. I expect a solid regression. Elliot didn’t play much last year and will come out hungry on a team that really wants to use him. In the end, it’s all very close.

 

With CMC, CJA is being somewhat underestimated. In standard, usage and TDS are more important for consistency and Mixon as well as Penny have a legitimate Bellcow opportunity while Guice will be fed the ball a ton including inside the 10. Just seems like those guys have a much higher ceiling along with more opportunity.

  • Like 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
40 minutes ago, Gohawks said:

Elliot is the safest option out of all of them. It’s really difficult to find any concern. Bell has been run into the ground and Johnson has the entire offense around him a question. With Gurley, it just seems like last season was an anomaly for the offense. It’s not that the offense isn’t good but rather they’re not first overall good. I expect a solid regression. Elliot didn’t play much last year and will come out hungry on a team that really wants to use him. In the end, it’s all very close.

 

With CMC, CJA is being somewhat underestimated. In standard, usage and TDS are more important for consistency and Mixon as well as Penny have a legitimate Bellcow opportunity while Guice will be fed the ball a ton including inside the 10. Just seems like those guys have a much higher ceiling along with more opportunity.

How much worse is the situation for DJ compared to zeke really? I mean, Arizona went 8-8 without DJ

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, bhawks489 said:

How much worse is the situation for DJ compared to zeke really? I mean, Arizona went 8-8 without DJ

 

OL is trash.

Rookie QB or Bradford -- don't know how well they'll connect with DJ.

Lost Arians, a great coach.

Fitz is good but WRs after that ...?

And I think Dallas might actually have a better defense.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
18 hours ago, bhawks489 said:

How much worse is the situation for DJ compared to zeke really? I mean, Arizona went 8-8 without DJ

Well, let's compare them. 

 

First, you have the offensive line which may be the most important part to the success of a RB. The Cowboys are right where they have been with a top 5 line and almost certainly a top 3 line. The Cardinals, on the other hand, are fully on the opposite side with one of the worst lines in football. Next, you have the entire QB situation. I don't think Dak is a good QB. In fact, he is underwhelming when you consider being able to produce at the expected level in todays NFL. However, he is a great QB in relation to production of Zeke. He is a good enough game manager where they won't consistently fail to move the ball but not good enough to where htye will air it out. This will create a great opportunity for Zeke to get production while also having opportunity to score. Cardinals have a QB that won't last and a rookie. This is another huge question mark. You also have to factor in the loss of a coach who was very good for DJs skill set.

 

I've been a huge supporter of DJ and all the above speaks immense volume to his talent that he can still be in the top 5 of almost every ranking. He is a great back that will certainly get his. However, he faces questions in regards to his surrounded that Elliot simply does not have. 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
13 minutes ago, Gohawks said:

Well, let's compare them. 

 

First, you have the offensive line which may be the most important part to the success of a RB. The Cowboys are right where they have been with a top 5 line and almost certainly a top 3 line. The Cardinals, on the other hand, are fully on the opposite side with one of the worst lines in football. Next, you have the entire QB situation. I don't think Dak is a good QB. In fact, he is underwhelming when you consider being able to produce at the expected level in todays NFL. However, he is a great QB in relation to production of Zeke. He is a good enough game manager where they won't consistently fail to move the ball but not good enough to where htye will air it out. This will create a great opportunity for Zeke to get production while also having opportunity to score. Cardinals have a QB that won't last and a rookie. This is another huge question mark. You also have to factor in the loss of a coach who was very good for DJs skill set.

 

I've been a huge supporter of DJ and all the above speaks immense volume to his talent that he can still be in the top 5 of almost every ranking. He is a great back that will certainly get his. However, he faces questions in regards to his surrounded that Elliot simply does not have. 

That’s all very fair.    I think they are a wash for the most part- with a few differences 

 

DJ is a more established pass catcher 

he’s not a knucklehead

proven performer without any qb and minimal line play.  

 

Zeke has a better line 

Hes an immense talent that feels like we’ve just scratched the surface 

 

 

I’m generally taking Gurley and Bell before either 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
18 minutes ago, Impreza178 said:

That’s all very fair.    I think they are a wash for the most part- with a few differences 

 

DJ is a more established pass catcher 

he’s not a knucklehead

proven performer without any qb and minimal line play.  

 

Zeke has a better line 

Hes an immense talent that feels like we’ve just scratched the surface 

 

 

I’m generally taking Gurley and Bell before either 

I honestly don't feel like Zeke being a knucklehead is a detriment to his production. I understand he got suspended but that was an absolutely ridiculous suspension and i don't particuarly like thw Cowboys. Goodell is a power hungry SOB that likes to make examples of the powerhouses (Cowboys and NE). I remember last year there were people posting how Gurley likes to turn up as a reason to not draft him. Worked out well...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, Gohawks said:

I honestly don't feel like Zeke being a knucklehead is a detriment to his production. I understand he got suspended but that was an absolutely ridiculous suspension and i don't particuarly like thw Cowboys. Goodell is a power hungry SOB that likes to make examples of the powerhouses (Cowboys and NE). I remember last year there were people posting how Gurley likes to turn up as a reason to not draft him. Worked out well...

Indeed-   But Goodell isn’t going anywhere-

so weigh it how you will. You’re hoping he won’t mess up again and get a long suspension. 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Gohawks said:

I honestly don't feel like Zeke being a knucklehead is a detriment to his production. I understand he got suspended but that was an absolutely ridiculous suspension and i don't particuarly like thw Cowboys. Goodell is a power hungry SOB that likes to make examples of the powerhouses (Cowboys and NE). I remember last year there were people posting how Gurley likes to turn up as a reason to not draft him. Worked out well...

 

That was me and I was just sharing his IG updates, I mentioned this in the Fournette thread but he's following the same exact habits (cars and bottles). I will be taking Fournette at #5 based on this analysis. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Can I throw in an underrated latavius Murray? Or is that another thread?

 

i feel he was better than he was treated on RW when he played for Oakland 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 6/12/2018 at 4:39 PM, Lord_Varys said:

 

OL is trash.

Rookie QB or Bradford -- don't know how well they'll connect with DJ.

Lost Arians, a great coach.

Fitz is good but WRs after that ...?

And I think Dallas might actually have a better defense.

 

Heck no

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.