From the Field 2019 Prospect Mock Draft

[Weekday Warrior 146]

Stumbled across this still-in-progress prospect mock draft between 16 industry writers and/or podcasters.

First 5 rounds are done and the list is updated here ... https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1xRe3iuvCXPXsbxj3l-_ouBnc7xUbKAfv_k2q9lVgyBw/htmlview#

Definitely skews toward young upside guys with Marco Luciano, Jasson Dominguez, Julio Rodriguez, and Kristian Robinson all going in the top 10 (!!).

[buccsfan22 23]

Seeing Kiriloff drop 10 spots from last year hurts lol

[Gobux1970 29]

Brendan Rogers and Tyler Trammell just keep dropping. 

[brockpapersizer 10,303]

Sean Murphy is a top 10 fantasy catcher right now and is at 130 on here. Funny. 

 

Theres a bunch of guys in front of him that I don't feel great about and I'm like, why wouldnt I watch a top 10 catcher right now over Estevan Florial. Seems nuts. I started the Luis Campusano thread here, love him. How he gets picked over Sean Murphy is bonkers.

Edited November 8 by brockpapersizer

[Gobux1970 29]

2 hours ago, brockpapersizer said:

Sean Murphy is a top 10 fantasy catcher right now and is at 130 on here. Funny. 

 

Theres a bunch of guys in front of him that I don't feel great about and I'm like, why wouldnt I watch a top 10 catcher right now over Estevan Florial. Seems nuts. I started the Luis Campusano thread here, love him. How he gets picked over Sean Murphy is bonkers.

 

I heard Chris Welsh discussing this draft on his podcast and they are drafting each position for a roster so the results may be a little skewed. 

[Gobux1970 29]

Here’s another first year player draft from prospect 1500 if anyone is interested.

 

https://www.prospects1500.com/fantasybaseball/the-2020-2earlymilbmock-draft-by-prospects1500/

[BigPapi44 1,017]

1 hour ago, Gobux1970 said:

Here’s another first year player draft from prospect 1500 if anyone is interested.

 

https://www.prospects1500.com/fantasybaseball/the-2020-2earlymilbmock-draft-by-prospects1500/

Since this was a draft of prospect mavens, gives a good sense of how guys are viewed, imo.  A bit surprised to see Vaughan fall to #26, which is after CJ Abrams (obviously someone is a big believer) and also Bobby Witt.

Edited November 19 by BigPapi44

[brockpapersizer 10,303]

23 hours ago, BigPapi44 said:

Since this was a draft of prospect mavens, gives a good sense of how guys are viewed, imo.  A bit surprised to see Vaughan fall to #26, which is after CJ Abrams (obviously someone is a big believer) and also Bobby Witt.

 

It's pretty dumb. I also think minor league drafts that require you to maintain certain positions is also dumb.  

[Slatykamora 2,534]

On 11/19/2019 at 10:24 AM, BigPapi44 said:

Since this was a draft of prospect mavens, gives a good sense of how guys are viewed, imo.  A bit surprised to see Vaughan fall to #26, which is after CJ Abrams (obviously someone is a big believer) and also Bobby Witt.

You are surprised 1st year players with 5 cat upside were drafted before a first year 4 cat upside player? Guy that picked Abrams probably fully believes he will grow into his 6'2 frame.

Not saying I agree, but it's defensible.

[BigPapi44 1,017]

On 11/20/2019 at 12:17 PM, Slatykamora said:

You are surprised 1st year players with 5 cat upside were drafted before a first year 4 cat upside player? Guy that picked Abrams probably fully believes he will grow into his 6'2 frame.

Not saying I agree, but it's defensible.

I'm saying that a lot of (fantasy) prospect sites have Vaughan ahead of pretty much all of them regardless 5 cat v. 4 cat.  For sure, it would seem that there are some that think otherwise, that's all. haha.