bigbossman 604 Posted March 25 Dynasty. Who wins or is it even Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
HOOTIE 879 Posted March 25 Bieber I like lux But bieber is top 10 and young 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
bigbossman 604 Posted March 25 7 hours ago, Thenewwildone8 said: Hell no. If Lux goes on to got 300 20-100-15 as a 22yr old would that change your opinion? Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
PhilFan 6 Posted March 25 It would create a debate,provided Puk has a healthy season and produces close to projections.Not many teams able to absorb loss of Bieb's stats. 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Rush2112 4,159 Posted March 25 Lux all by himself wins!! It's not even close! Elite up & coming catcher in a lethal offense. Move the buckeye state & win you're league. 2 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
F@ndemonium 368 Posted March 25 League settings would allow for a more informed response, but in a vacuum take Bieber. Puk's injury and Lux struggles against southpaws/potential to platoon this season w/Hernandez, would suggest that the market for Bieber is significantly greater. Even if you believe in Puk and Lux long term, the current market play favors Bieber decisively...even in a dynasty environment imo. 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Thenewwildone8 751 Posted March 25 6 hours ago, bigbossman said: If Lux goes on to got 300 20-100-15 as a 22yr old would that change your opinion? It would make me think for sure, but we don’t know if he will, while we know that Bieber is definitely an ace. Even if he did do that, I feel that Bieber has more value. 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Bandito 2,505 Posted March 26 11 hours ago, Rush2112 said: Lux all by himself wins!! It's not even close! Elite up & coming catcher in a lethal offense. Move the buckeye state & win you're league. That clinches it — Bieber it is!! 3 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
HOOTIE 879 Posted March 26 13 hours ago, Rush2112 said: Lux all by himself wins!! It's not even close! Elite up & coming catcher in a lethal offense. Move the buckeye state & win you're league. Catcher? Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Thenewwildone8 751 Posted March 26 3 hours ago, HOOTIE said: Catcher? Rush doesn’t practice social distancing with his alcohol collection. 4 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Richard Kimble 105 Posted March 26 You can't even consider Puk until he gets back on the mound. I know it looks like a buying opportunity, but in reality its a chance for you to get stuck with a pitcher before he needs TJ. Syndergaard's came out of nowhere, seemingly. There haven't been any good reports on Puk yet, so ignore him until further notice. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Thenewwildone8 751 Posted March 26 1 hour ago, Richard Kimble said: You can't even consider Puk until he gets back on the mound. I know it looks like a buying opportunity, but in reality its a chance for you to get stuck with a pitcher before he needs TJ. Syndergaard's came out of nowhere, seemingly. There haven't been any good reports on Puk yet, so ignore him until further notice. Another good point. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
bigbossman 604 Posted March 28 On 3/26/2020 at 2:18 PM, Richard Kimble said: You can't even consider Puk until he gets back on the mound. I know it looks like a buying opportunity, but in reality its a chance for you to get stuck with a pitcher before he needs TJ. Syndergaard's came out of nowhere, seemingly. There haven't been any good reports on Puk yet, so ignore him until further notice. Puk already had TJ, so that risk is mitigated more than someone who hasn't yet. Also he looked good out of the bullpen last year... Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
bigbossman 604 Posted March 28 (edited) He will do the deal if I add Riley So Bieber for Lux, Puk and Riley Trading Riley means I have to play Edman at 3B all season... My rotation would be: Mad Max, Kershaw, Bieber, Montas, Ray, Price, Tanaka, Keuchel (with Sale out with TJ) Edited March 28 by bigbossman Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
shorthop 67 Posted March 28 If you can get Bieber with that package, jump on it. Elite young arms are hard to come by and your sending a package full of questions. Can Puk stay healthy? Who is the real Riley(the Braves dont even seem to know as reports where that Carmargo was going to win the 3B job)? And Lux hasn't proven anything yet. He should be good but we've seen it 100 times before when guys just cant translate their minor league numbers to the bigs. I wouldnt be surprised at all if this time next year (if we have a 2020 season) we would be talking about Bieber as a CY winner, Puk being moved to the pen because of health concerns, Riley being a non factor in AAA and Lux entering his sophomore year trying to improve on a disappointing rookie start. Or....Puk stays healthy and proves to be a top of rotation talent, Riley proves his 2019 streak wasn't a fluke and Lux lives up to his hype. It will take 2 of those 3 things to happen for this trade to brake even in my opinion. Soooooo....jump on Bieber is my opinion! 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Richard Kimble 105 Posted March 28 6 minutes ago, shorthop said: It will take 2 of those 3 things to happen for this trade to brake even in my opinion. Soooooo....jump on Bieber is my opinion! I agree, and I think 1 of 3 is likeliest outcome. Break even. Sorry, come from a tribe of English teachers. 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Bandito 2,505 Posted March 29 20 hours ago, bigbossman said: My rotation would be: Mad Max, Kershaw, Bieber, Montas, Ray, Price, Tanaka, Keuchel (with Sale out with TJ) Looks pretty good to me! 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
